To begin considering the role of assessment in service-learning,
let's begin with reviewing a basic premise about assessment in general. Teachers are responsible for
assessing student learning in all areas of the curriculum. They must gather together reliable
information that helps them evaluate student achievement. This is part of the ongoing curriculum
planning that begins with any unit of instruction. Effective assessment includes:
- Collecting evidence of student learning
- Analyzing student achievement in relation to content and performance standards
- Reporting student achievement
- Improving instruction
All of these aspects of effective assessment need to be applied to service-learning activity. A
carefully developed service experience will include a method for collecting evidence of student
learning. This should occur early in the planning process.
Level of student participation in the service-learning activity itself provides evidence of student
learning in any of the content standards that are related to the service project. Students are able to
demonstrate learning by putting new skills into practice. The role of the teacher, then, is to be able
to observe, identify, and report that learning. What tools can a teacher utilize to observe, identify,
and report the student learning that occurs from participation in the service project?
Read this excerpt written by a teacher candidate about a service project she developed:
"After my second grade students explored railroad safety as part of a larger unit on safety, they
conducted a survey of the local railroad crossings. They determined that one crossing was not safe
for children who needed to cross that particular street on the way to school. The students developed
and made posters regarding railroad safety that they then posted around the school. They also made
oral presentations to several other classes. Then they wrote a letter to the city council expressing
their concern about the one crossing that was not safe. My students demonstrated many language arts
skills as part of the service activity that showed they were making progress in several content
standards. I was very pleased with the outcomes of the unit not to mention that the students felt
that they had made a real contribution to the level of safety in the community."
Step One: In your journal, respond to the following questions:
Entry #13:
- What service activities in this unit provide the student teacher with evidence of academic learning? In which academic areas?
- What aspects of the project would provide evidence of a gain in the students' development of civic responsibility and concern for the community?
- What assessment tool(s) might this student teacher have utilized to collect evidence of student learning?
Step Two: Examine the assessment form below.
| Student's Name: |
_______________________________ |
| Teacher's Name: |
_______________________________ |
| Site/Project: |
_______________________________ |
| Project Description: |
_______________________________ |
| |
_______________________________ |
| Method of Evaluation of Progress (check all that apply) |
| _____ |
Formal Test |
| _____ |
Observation |
| _____ |
Logs/Journal |
| _____ |
Interview |
| _____ |
Portfolio |
| _____ |
Peer Rating |
| _____ |
Behavior Checklist |
| _____ |
Attitude Scale |
| _____ |
Other: please describe:
_______________________________ _______________________________
|
| Describe (or attach)
Method of Scoring (and Instrument - Rubric, points, grade, etc.) |
|
___________________________________________________ |
___________________________________________________
|
| Student Results: ___________________________________ |
|
___________________________________________________ |
___________________________________________________
|
| Other comments/sources
of evidence of student progress/ learning: |
|
___________________________________________________ |
___________________________________________________
|
|
Step Three: Complete this entry in your journal.
Entry #14:
Discuss ways in which students in primary, intermediate, and middle school grades might demonstrate what they have learned
from participating in service-learning.
Step Four: Email these assignments to your instructor in an attachment.