A  New Interpretation of the Caste System

 by Marisa Cox

     Caste is a word that is of European origin, and can be used in a variety of ways.  In this context, it will be used as a noun to denote an abstract principle or a particular social group; as an adjective to describe the quality of this principle or the character of the group.  The notion of the caste system first appears to have been established in 1000 BC, in the hymn of the Rgveda.  In this hymn, four varnas, the Sanskrit word for caste, are presented: Brahmana, Rajanya (later referred to as Kshatriya), Vaishya and Sudra.  Each of these had emanated from the “lord of the beings” Purusha, who was sacrificed at the beginning of time. (Quigley, 18).  “When they divided Purusha…his mouth became the Brahman; his arms were made into the Rajanya; his thighs the Vaishyas; from his feet the shudra was born.” (Rigveda x, 90;11-12) (Quigley, 7).  In the code of Manu, a later Hindu law book, each varna is represented as fundamentally different in function, and each is required to perform a paticular function as it’s “divinely ordained duty.”(Quigley, 8).
     Here is where the concept of caste takes form.  Each caste is required to fulfill some duty in the society, and this is how the society functions.  Because each duty is different, a principle of hierarchy is established; which is to say that some duties are pure and others are not.  The people who are born into the caste which performs the “pure” duties belong to a higher caste than those who perform impure duties, or who are just impure.  “The superiority and the superior purity are identical; it is in this sense that, ideologically, distinction of purity is the foundation of status.” (Dumont 1980:56, Quigley,25).
 According to idealist theory, there are three essential characteristics of the caste system; these being separation, interdependence, and hierarchy.  Separation pertains to matters of marriage and contact.  Interdependence is such that each group has in theory and tradition a profession or duty from which its members can only depart in certain circumstances and within limits.  Hierarchy then ranks the groups as relatively superior or inferior to each other.(Quigley, 26).
     Although inequality does exist in the caste system, each caste’s duty is essential to maintain the villages' way of life.  The Brahman’s, the highest caste, are often priests and provide the society with a way to worship the gods of the Hindu religion and to pray to them.  The Kshatriyas are seen as the warriors in the ancient histories, but in modern day are often the rulers.  Their duty is to protect, therefore they are the only caste that is allowed to carry arms.  As protectors, they provide society with laws and to make sure people are safe.  The Vaishyas are the merchants.  Their duty is trade, and they provide the villages with the necessities.  The Sudras are the servants, and they are there to serve the higher castes.  The Untouchables, the lowest caste, do the most menial of work, often cleaning up feces and other dirty jobs as such. (Lecture, 3-2-99). (Oman, 85). (Hazari,119.)
     The way of life in India may be seen as a complicated system of unfair inequalities to our western eyes and minds.  However, in India, this system has existed efficiently for thousands of years.  We may look at it as a harsh separation of people who would normally be equal in a different culture,  but to the Hindu’s it is a natural way of life and afterlife, because while there may be inequalities in the society, they are governed by the gods of karma and dharma. (Lecture, 3-2-99).   The caste’s interactions with one another is based on one’s rank; rank differences and feelings of solidarity between persons drawn from different castes are immediately observable.  An interaction between a Brahman and an Untouchable is often marked by an elaborate display of  homage on the part of the Untouchable, while the Brahman expresses his power and position with harsh authority and swear words.  Similarly, relations of cordial alliance between members of two high ranking castes will be characterized by mutual intimacy, gossip and frank discussion of certain topics pertaining to them. (McGilvray, 97-99).
 These theories of caste that I have explained are only the idealist view.  There are many other abstract theories that exist, and one of them is Hocart's comparative study, which is what is discussed in An Interpretation of Caste, and is what I will now discuss.

  
  Learn more about Social Class In India
 Learn about Violence Against Untouchables 

 
 

   

  These theories of caste that I have explained are only the idealist view.  There are many other abstract theories that exist, and one of them is Hocart's comparative study, which is what is discussed in An Interpretation of Caste, and is what I will now discuss. 

 
 

go to next page