English 101: Genre Responses
Q: What is a genre response?
A: A genre response is a piece of
writing
composed in response to a specific reading. The difference between a
genre
response and a more traditional reader response is that the writer
molds
the response in a specific genre (more about those below). We will do
several of these in class that you may use to generate your quarter
project's multigenre paper. Examples of young students composing genre
responses can be found throughout Lois Burdett's children's version of A
Midsummer Night's Dream (e.g. when the students write about part of
the story in a new form, like a note from one character to another, or
an escape plan, or a diary entry).
Q: What does a genre response include?
A: A genre response is always comprised
of two parts: the response itself, and a "writer's note" that explains
a little about the response.
Q: How long does a genre response need
to be?
A: There is no fixed or specified
length
for a genre response. However, the responses you write will always need
to demonstrate two things. First, they must show an in-depth
understanding
of and engagement with one or more of the class readings. Second, they
must demonstrate that the writer understands how the specific genre in
which he or she
is writing works (that is, its preferred conventions and modes of
expressions).
Q: What should be included in the writer's
note?
A: The writer's note should do two
things. First, it should tell what idea you were trying to get across,
and what connection that idea had to the reading. Second, it should
explain why you chose to deal with that idea in the genre you chose.
Q: What are some different genres that
can be used in the genre responses?
A: The following is a brief, and
necessarily
incomplete, list of genres that you might try using in your responses.
You should always feel free to try things not listed here.
-
letter
-
email
-
advertisement
-
magazine article
-
want ad
-
news report
-
poem
-
dialogue
-
speech
-
play
-
summary
-
talk show
-
class syllabus
-
analysis
-
sitcom
-
movie review
-
journal entry
-
book cover
-
CD liner notes
-
fashion magazine article
-
instruction manual
-
teacher's paper comments
-
advice column
-
cartoon
-
interview
-
quiz
-
menu
-
recipe
-
encyclopedia entry
-
play-by-play
-
essay
-
ransom note
-
radio broadcast
-
tabloid article
-
greeting card
-
obituary
-
eulogy
-
thank you note
-
grocery list
-
map
-
book jacket
-
wanted poster
-
diary entry
-
post card
-
eyewitness account
-
lab analysis
-
collage
-
graph or chart
-
cereal box
-
instruction manual
Q: Are my genre responses
the same thing as my multi-genre paper?
A: No. The multi-genre paper may end up
using many, some, a few, or none of the genre responses you write. Look
in the course packet for examples of multi-genre papers to get a sense
of how they work. From a reader's perspective, a multi-genre paper is a
collection of short writings in a variety of genres that, when taken
together,
make a point or argument about an idea or issue that the writer wishes
to explore. From the perspective of a writer (that's you!), a
multi-genre
paper is the opportunity to look at an idea or question that is raised
in readings or discussions, and that you want to examine from a number
of different perspectives and genres; the idea is to more fully explore
and articulate the idea by seeing it in different ways. The genres will
be framed by an introductory piece that prepares the reader to
understand
the genre pieces that follow, and an endnote that explains the
background
for each of the genre pieces within the paper. Again, referring to the
examples in the course packet will help you see how these papers work.
Q: Why do a multi-genre piece instead of
a traditional literary analysis?
A: The reasons are threefold. First,
the
multi-genre paper allows a writer to practice more than one kind of
writing,
and requires the writer to consider how specific forms of writing
accomplish
different ends. This ability to identify type of writing with its
purpose
or rhetorical function is a basic tenet of literary study. Second,
since
nearly all students in English 101 are preservice elementary school
teachers,
the multi-genre paper provides practice with the linking of critical
thinking
and creative expression; school-aged children are often required to
write
both creatively and critically (look in the state content standards for
specifics). The multi-genre paper is an assignment model that can be
adapted
to grade-school students, who can use it to demonstrate their ability
to
write creatively and think critically. Finally, a well-constructed
multi-genre
paper can make the same points, criticisms, and arguments that a
traditional
analysis makes; it is simply in a different--neither better nor
worse--format.
Q: What are some examples of genre
responses
I might try out?
A: Here are some genre response
possibilities
for a few of the readings in the course:
- Classic Fairy Tales (any)
- Rewrite the tale from a first-person point
of view, choosing any character as the one who narrates the action
- Update the tale by bringing the characters
and/or events into the contemporary world
- Write the tale in the form of a newspaper
article
- Write a menu for items at a restaurant in
the land of fairy tales (think about such things as the witch in Hansel
and Gretel or the kids in The Juniper Tree or Pippety Pew)
- Write the transcript of an episode of The
Jerry Springer Show featuring some of the dysfunctional families
featured in the fairy tales (e.g. the father-daughter problems in some
of the Cinderella variants)
- Briar Rose
- Write an internal monologue that shows
what Gemma is really thinking about as she speaks her final words to
Becca
- Write the obituary for Gemma
- Write a diary entry for Stan that explores
his feelings for Becca
- Write the phone conversation between Shana
and Sylvia when they discuss Becca's trip to Poland
- "The Yellow Wallpaper"
-
Write diary entries for John, the narrator's
husband,
showing a different perspective on the narrator's descent from sanity.
-
Write a medical file entry on the narrator
-
Highlight a number of words the narrator
uses in the
story that you find significant, and use those words in a free-verse
poem
that captures the narrator's feelings in the story
-
Write an advertisement for a
housekeeper/nurse whose
responsibilities include caring for both the narrator and her baby
-
"A Woman on a Roof"
-
Write an internal monologue for one of the
characters
in the story whose thoughts we do not see (Stanley, the woman on the
roof,
Harry)
-
Write a dialogue between the woman on the
roof and
the narrator in "Yellow Wallpaper"
-
Write a letter from the woman on the roof to
the construction
company that employed Tom, Harry, and Stanley
-
Write an advertisement for the clothing worn
by the
woman
-
"First Shag in Ages"
-
Write a description of what Dianne does
during a typical
school day
-
Write what a sociologist or anthropologist
might think
about the scene in the "meat market" bar
-
Write a play scene with Renton as a primary
character,
but with the setting changed to Chico
-
Write an Oprah show scene with Dianne, the
woman on
the roof, and the narrator from "Yellow Wallpaper" as guests discussing
women's rights
-
Any story/poem/play:
-
Write the obituary of a central character.
The manner
and time of death can be made up for you for any character still alive
during the scope of the literary piece. Explore what about the
character
might be remembered after his or her death.
-
Assume that you're an archeologist a couple
thousand
years in the future, and that you've uncovered the literary piece to
which
you're writing the genre response. What might an archeologist see in
the
literature? What might it tell the archeologist about the culture that
produced the literature?
-
Rewrite what you think is an important
scene, event,
etc. in the literary piece, using a different genre (e.g. you might
rewrite
a narrative in poetic form, or as a play scene) to showcase that
important
idea.
-
Write a narrative of your own voice piecing
together
what you thought as you read the literary piece. For this, you might
want
to use as models the writings in Mosaic of Thought, in which
the
authors show us how they determined a personal meaning for a number of
different readings.
-
Rewrite all or part of the literary piece,
changing
some aspect of the piece that you find important, in order to explore
the
significance of that element. For instance, you might change the gender
of a character, or an aspect of the setting (change the location, or
the
time period), and see what effect that change has on the literature.