Rivoli Questions Ch. 8 Key
1. What is the "trade regime" that Rivoli continues to mention in
this chapter?
Rivoli is referring to the textile and apparel manufacturers'
lobbyists, US congressmen and the system of tariffs and quotas that protect US
manufacturers from competitors in China and other countries.
2. What point do Figure 8.1 and 8.2 make about changes in the textile and
apparel industry in the US? Use the terms workers, technology and
production in your answer.
Figures 8.1 and 8.2 show that during the past 15 years, production
per worker in the US textile and apparel industry has increased while the
number of workers has decreased. Mechanization of production (technology)
has caused these changes.
3. Explain Rivoli's statement, "textile jobs are not going to China;
textile jobs are just going, period." Use the terms technology,
labor productivity, China and ten in your answer.
From 1995 to 2002 China lost 10 times as many textile manufacturing
jobs as the US. Not all of these jobs migrated to some country with lower
production costs. Most job losses were caused by the dramatic increases
in labor productivity caused by rapidly improved technology.
4. The "Own Worst Enemy" section is complicated.
What is the section's basic point?
The protectionist policies (tariffs and quotas) have made US textile
manufacturers less competitive because the tariffs have increased the cost of
manufacturing.
5. How do quotas cause Chinese manufacturers to focus production on LL Bean
polos instead of Fruit of the Loom briefs?
Instead of briefs, I should have said t-shirts. The US gave
China a number (a quota) of cotton knit shirts that they could export to the
US. To maximize their profit Chinese producers manufactured and exported
the higher cost type of cotton knit shirt.
6. Explain how quotas force products and laborers to move. Use these
terms in your answer: Esquel, globe-trotting corporations, trade barriers.
Esquel is the largest producer of t-shirts in the world. Trade
barriers, like quotas, forced them to become a globe-trotting
corporation. When they could not get quota for t-shirts in Hong
Kong, they moved production to Malaysia and then Sri Lanka. These
geographic shifts in production required that cotton, managers and, sometimes,
workers had to be shipped to new locations.
Your shirt's label might be misleading.
7. Why is there a quota market? Because quotas are a fixed
option that have market (albeit black market) value.
8. How does it work? Countries buy and sell each
other’s quotas.
9. How does quota trading affect the price you pay for
apparel? The cost of quota is added to the price of producing apparel
and, therefore, you pay a higher price.
10. Does the quota system save US manufacturing jobs? Not many and at a high price.
11. What is Wal-Mart's role in the race to the bottom?
As the world's largest retailer, Wal-Mart has been able to negotiate
extremely low prices from its suppliers of textiles and apparel. This has
put some US manufacturers out of business it forced some Chinese manufacturers
to cut costs by paying low wages and providing poor working conditions.
12. Which countries were the "(Unintended) Winners? "dozens
of small developing countries" Countries like Bangladesh and Mauritius
were able to develop textile and apparel manufacturing industries because the
US, with its MFA, did not allow China to provide more of our textiles and
apparel. What did they win? They won a
sort of economic aid from the US. By limiting China we gave
those small countries an incentive to become low cost manufacturers.
13. Summarize Rivoli's example of a free trade-protection controversy
concerning apparel from the 17th century. Use the following terms
in your summary: corpse, summer, entrepreneurial instincts, printing,
wool, cotton, India, laws
Great Britain tried to protect its woolen industry by limiting imports
of comfortable colorful cotton apparel from India. The British parliament
created laws to protect the wool industry from competition. For example:
corpses in coffins had to be dressed in wool clothing; cotton garments could be
worn only in summer; and, cotton garments printed, stained or painted in India
(calicoes) could not be worn. These restrictions stimulated the
entrepreneurial instincts of some British citizens who developed a mechanized
cotton fabric printing process.
14. What was the most significant result of the protection of the wool
industry? England's Industrial Revolution, which initially was
devoted to apparel manufacture.