Frequently Asked Questions by Instructors

Do students have to register with ARC?

Students with disabilities must be registered with Accessibility Resource Center (ARC) if they intend to request reasonable accommodations. It is not advisable that instructors provide requested accommodations to students without the student’s registration with ARC. Being registered with ARC provides the student with a more consistent, organized, and supported approach to receiving accommodations, as well as allowing ARC to provide consultation for instructors regarding what is appropriate and reasonable. However, instructors can provide approved accommodations within their own classes and departments, such as extended time on exams or taking exams in a distraction-reduced environment, if it is agreed upon by the student and the student’s ARC Accessibility Advisor.

When do students with disabilities have to notify instructors?

It is good to have a syllabus statement asking students to notify you as soon as possible. However, there is nothing in law or policy that requires more than that they notify you in a timely way of their status and make requests for accommodation in a “timely” manner. In addition, students register with ARC throughout any given semester, from the beginning to the last several weeks. We do not need to provide retroactive accommodation, but we do need to respond to a student who follows procedures, even if they provide notification and make an accommodation request in the last few weeks of class. “Timely” should be taken to mean with enough time for a reasonable person to react to the request. We ask that students notify ARC of an exam request at least three days before the actual date of the exam, although we will accept exam requests that miss the deadline if the instructor is willing to send us an exam to administer.

What are some reasons students do not disclose to instructors right away?

Disclosure is very difficult for most people. There are several reasons why students may not disclose their disability and need for accommodations at the beginning of the semester. Some students have disabilities with waxing and waning symptoms and disclosure is only necessary if they have an exacerbation of their disability or their condition worsens. Students try to avoid unnecessary disclosure. Also, most Chico State students are new to personally managing their disability and all that goes along with it. In K-12, students with disabilities are accommodated in very different ways and through a process that is managed for them. When they arrive on our campus, they are catapulted into a new world of personal responsibility for managing their disability, learning how to talk about their disability and necessary accommodations, and learning how to advocate for themselves appropriately. We consider this a learning process and work to help students develop skills to be proficient in managing their disability, accommodations, and disclosure by the time they graduate.

Is a student required to divulge the nature of the disability?

No. Students are not required to tell you the nature of their disabilities or to provide copies of their disability documentation. ARC is the authorized campus entity charged with documenting disabilities and recommending reasonable accommodations at Chico State. It is recommended that instructors do not require medical notes or documentation for students with disabilities.

What do I do if I suspect a student has a disability?

Do not tell a student you think they have a disability. Approach the student as you would any other student having difficulty in class. Inquire about what might be impacting the student's progress in class. A student with a disability will likely disclose at this time if the difficulties are disability related. Refer the student to ARC if they disclose a disability or indicate they suspect a disability. If neither of these scenarios occurs, we recommend providing the student with a list of campus resources including ARC.

What are reasonable accommodations?

Reasonable accommodations are specific recommendations or strategies, technology, or aids that are needed to accommodate a disability without compromising the integrity of the academic program.

Reasonable accommodations should:

• Mitigate the impact of the disability.
• Level the playing field for students with disabilities.
• Be reasonable in relation to the course.
• Ensure a student’s access to instructional material.
• Ensure a student’s ability to demonstrate competency of curriculum.

Reasonable accommodations should not:

• Water down curricula or compromise academic integrity.
• Fundamentally alter any essential elements of the curriculum or academic program.
• Ensure that all students with disabilities are successful.
• Consume extra personal time from the instructor to re-teach or tutor the student.

Why do students use accommodations sometimes and not other times?

Students are determined to be eligible to request accommodations under the umbrella of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Students have the responsibility to identify themselves to their various instructors and to request a specific adjustment for certain situations, including each exam or quiz for which they wish an accommodation. They may request the specific accommodation in some instances and not in others. Frequently, students will take the first exam for a class to see how they do with the time and setting allowed for the exam while subsequent exams they may ask for accommodations. Additionally, there are many things that can impact the way a person functions related to their disability, such as:

• Diagnosis
• Adjustment to the disability
• Compensatory strategies currently used
• Co-occurring issues and diagnosis
• Environmental issues
• Treatment, therapy, and medications
• Waxing and waning symptoms

Because the student did not request an accommodation in one instance does not negate their right to ask for it in another.

May I fail a student with a disability?

Yes. It is possible to fail a student with a disability. The laws mandate access to education, not guaranteed academic success. When an instructor has provided reasonable academic accommodations, that are required to comply with the law, and the student does not meet the course requirements, then failing a student is proper and lawful. The following is a compliance checklist that may be helpful:

• Stand by academic standards and freedoms, which include full and equitable access to academic programs.
• Provide verbal and written notice to your students of your willingness to accommodate. For example, "I encourage students with disabilities to discuss accommodations with me." See sample syllabi statement(opens in new window) on the ARC website.
• Communicate clear and concise expectations for performance to your students. Distinguish between essential and non-essential components of the course.
• Respect requests for reasonable accommodations.
• Permit students to use auxiliary aides and technologies that ensure access (examples include note-takers, sign language interpreters, readers, scribes, research assistants, recording devices, and assistive listening devices).
• Ensure your course materials, whether printed or electronic, are accessible and available in alternative formats.
• Consult with ARC if you have questions when a student requests accommodations.
• Keep student disability-related information strictly confidential.

Can an instructor forbid a student with a disability from using a recording device in class?

An instructor is typically required to allow a student to record their course if recording the class is determined to be an appropriate accommodation for a student's disability. Recording devices are specifically mentioned in Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act as a means of providing full participation in educational programs and activities. Occasionally, classroom discussion reveals items of a personal nature about students. If open discussions tend to reveal personal information, it would be appropriate to ask the student with a disability to turn off the recording device during these discussions. To alleviate concerns with sharing instructional content and “intellectual property," ARC asks students to sign a recording agreement that states they will not share or distribute information.

What is Assignment Extension and Attendance Flexibility and who may use these accommodations?

Please refer to the Assignment Extension(opens in new window) and Attendance Flexibility(opens in new window) pages on our website for information regarding these accommodations. 

What test accommodations are available for students with disabilities?

Test accommodations are individually determined for each student based on the specific impact a student's disability has on the test process. Accommodations can include, but are not limited to, extended time, low-distraction environment, calculator, spell-check, private room, reader, scribe, interpreter, computer, adaptive equipment (screen reader, voice output, CCTV), Braille, large print, breaks, and accessible furniture. The University must provide any accommodation that minimizes the effect of the disability on the testing process if the accommodation does not alter any essential feature of the curriculum and is not prohibitively expensive.

How do students with disabilities become eligible for test accommodations?

Students must provide ARC with detailed documentation that shows the specific ways in which their disability impacts test-taking.

What is a Low Distraction Environment (LDE)?

A low distraction environment is a test setting that has as few distractions as possible compared to the classroom setting. It can be, but does not have to be, a private room. It should be an environment with reduced noise (no phones, talking, etc.) and reduced distractions like people coming and going. If you need assistance determining whether a specific environment qualifies as low distraction, please contact ARC. Please note: If students are approved for a low distraction environment and extra time, it is not a reasonable accommodation to have the student start the exam in the classroom and then move them to another location to receive extra time.

How is extended time fair?

The Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) states, "The results of an examination should accurately reflect an individual's aptitude or achievement level or whatever the test purports to measure, rather than reflecting an individual's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills." The courts have held repeatedly that a lengthening of the standard examination period is an appropriate accommodation for some students with disabilities. For example, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ordered the State Board of Bar Examiners to allow double the standard time on the bar exam for an applicant with Dyslexia and Attention Deficit Disorder. Similarly, the State District Court for the Western District of New York ruled that a State Bar applicant with a visual impairment must be allowed a four-day examination period rather than the standard two-day period.

Instructors should be aware that there may be times when a student’s accommodation of extended time creates a conflict with other exams, such as during mid-terms and finals. If this is the case, the student or ARC Accessibility Advisor will contact instructors to reschedule an exam.

Do I still have to honor extra time on exams if I “build extra time into the exam” for all students?

Yes. Accommodations are designed to “level the playing field” or to provide equity opportunities. This is different than all students getting the same thing. Regardless of how you construct your exam with respect to time, students who are eligible for extra time are still guaranteed this right under the law.

Can I deny the student’s exam accommodations if summative information makes the accommodation seem unreasonable to me (i.e., student performs at the top of the class without accommodations or student has poor attendance)?

No. Using summative information as justification to deny an exam with accommodations is not legally justifiable. Reasonable accommodations are a civil right, not a privilege.

How can I accommodate students on pop quizzes?

Instructors may find it challenging to provide testing accommodations recommended for students with disabilities for pop quizzes due to scheduling conflicts, the nature of testing accommodations needed by the student (i.e., assistive technology, extended time, distraction-reduced setting, etc.), or the need for prior arrangements if the student would typically be taking the quiz at ARC. Students have a right to reasonable accommodations and instructors have a right to evaluate learning. Reasonable accommodations are not required if it fundamentally alters the nature of the activity in question. The goal of accommodating a pop quiz is to ensure reasonable accommodations and maintain the integrity of the evaluation process, such that the accommodation does not fundamentally alter the evaluation process.

Possible strategies to accommodate pop quizzes:

• Allow student to take the quiz with the class, stop when classmates stop, and grade only the portion completed.
• Offer a substitute assignment.
• Evaluate the purpose of pop quizzes and possibly eliminate them.
• Set regular dates for quizzes so the student and instructor can plan for and accommodate needs, consider testing at ARC due to the need for assistive technology, document conversion, use of scribe, or audio format of quiz, etc.
• Use the campus learning platform for quizzes; assign quizzes to be taken at specific times and for a specific length of time (keeping in mind that some students with disabilities have extended time on exams as an accommodation).
• Allow student to take a quiz with the class and stay after the class meeting is over to complete the quiz  (instructor will need to verify with the student ahead of time that student is available after class session and wouldn't miss another class by committing to stay).

I use a clicker in my class. What accessibility issues should I be aware of?

Currently, ARC recommends the use of I Clickers in the classroom. I Clickers have recently undergone rigorous accessibility tests and have had great success. For example, the I Clicker has a specialized device that provides a vibration function and provides Braille stickers for the buttons. Please contact the Technology Equity and Inclusion(opens in new window) (TEIN) office for questions or support specific to clicker use and accommodating students.

How does the use of a textbook rental affect students who require their textbooks in alternate format?

Chico State and the Chico State Wildcat Store have collaborated so students who require alternate media services can still rent a textbook and have it converted into an alternate format without additional charge to the student for damage to the book.

Do I have to approve retroactive accommodations?

Students have the right to request disability-related accommodations at any time. Accommodations begin when the student is determined eligible for services. Instructors are not required to honor accommodations retroactively.

Can I deny an accommodation?

No. The only reason an instructor may not honor an approved accommodation is if that accommodation fundamentally alters the nature of the academic activity, essential elements, or requirement of a course. Opinions about fairness, concerns about cheating, or inconvenience of the instructor are not sufficient or legally defensible reasons to deny an accommodation. The onus is on the instructor or department to demonstrate that an activity (e.g., spelling) is essential. There needs to be a pedagogically defensible reason to deny an accommodation (e.g., the use of spell-check). This is a deliberative process. It is important to consult with ARC Accessibility Advisors before denying an accommodation so that ARC can ensure instructors fulfill their obligation of the deliberative process. The following is provided to help clarify this issue.

Bowling Green is one of the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) cases that maps out a process for determining essential elements of a course or program:

Bowling Green State University, OCR DOCKET NUMBER: 05982143 (August 31, 1999)
"...A key issue is how OCR should review an institution's determination of whether a specific standard or requirement is an essential program requirement that cannot be modified. OCR cannot require an institution to waive or lessen essential requirements. OCR can require a modification of the requirement, if the requested modification does not lower academic standards, fundamentally alter the nature of the program or impose an undue burden on the College or University, and the modification meets the underlying reason for the requirement.

OCR reviews whether the determination by an institution that a requirement is an essential requirement is educationally rationally justifiable. The requirement should be essential to the educational purpose or objective of a program or class. For example, it may be an essential requirement for a teacher education program that a student complete student teaching to, in part, demonstrate the ability to maintain class discipline and develop lesson plans. In this example, there may not be an appropriate alternative to completing student teaching to demonstrate that the student can maintain classroom discipline. There may be an appropriate alternative for a student to demonstrate the ability to develop lesson plans, such as preparation of lesson plans based on different written factual situations..."

“...OCR may review the process that a post-secondary institution utilizes to determine whether an academic requirement is an essential requirement. Courts indicate that an appropriate process should have the following elements:

1. The decision is made by a group of people, who are trained, knowledgeable and experienced in the area;
2. The decision makers consider a series of alternatives as essential requirements; and,
3. The decision should be a careful, thoughtful and rational review of the academic program and its requirements.

An example of this process in the context of a case involving a student teaching program would be that the Dean of Education and a group of experienced staff and professors meet over a period of time to consider a series of options or standards. After a careful, thoughtful review, they develop a group of essential requirements for graduation with a teaching degree that are rationally based on their knowledge of teaching and experience in the field.

OCR strongly recommends that the decision should be documented, including an explanation for the purposes or objectives of the academic program and how the essential requirement is necessary to achieve those objectives. It is very helpful for this to be clearly documented prior to a challenge..."